A near-Earth object that astronomers believed was an asteroid for nearly three decades has been unmasked as a faint, active comet, revealing a case of cosmic mistaken identity that could help improve planetary defense.
The object, known since its discovery in 1998 as 1998 SH2, appeared to be an ordinary asteroid. It follows a 4.5-year orbit around the sun and showed no obvious signs of cometary activity, such as the glowing coma or tail produced when sunlight vaporizes surface ice.
However, during a close pass about 2 million miles (3 million kilometers) from Earth in August 2025, researchers using NASA’s Deep Space Network planetary radar system noticed something unexpected: The object wasn’t where orbital predictions said it should be, according to a statement from the space agency. That discrepancy prompted scientists to take a closer look, and what they found surprised them.
Using decades of precision optical astrometry — measurements of the object’s position against background stars — researchers found that gravity alone couldn’t explain its irregular motion. Instead, they detected tiny nongravitational forces consistent with jets of gas escaping from the object’s surface as hidden ice warmed in sunlight.
“After we measured the nongravitational perturbations affecting the motion of 1998 SH2 and recognized they weren’t compatible with the object being an asteroid, we suspected the object could be an active comet,” Davide Farnocchia, lead author of the study and navigation engineer with NASA’s Center for Near-Earth Object Studies at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, said in the statement.
To test the idea, the team observed the object with the European Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope in Chile and the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope atop Mauna Kea. The observations revealed a faint but unmistakable comet tail, confirming the object’s true identity.
The discovery earned 1998 SH2 a second designation: P/1998 SH2, officially recognizing it as a comet. Beyond solving the mystery, the finding has important implications for planetary defense.
Unlike rocky asteroids, comets can subtly change course as gas escaping from their surfaces acts like tiny thrusters. Identifying those nongravitational forces allows scientists to more accurately predict an object’s future orbit and assess any potential impact risk.
“This work shows the importance of continuously tracking near-Earth objects,” Farnocchia said in the statement. “Because of outgassing, the motion of comets is more significantly perturbed than that of asteroids.
“Detecting these perturbations can be an important diagnostic tool for planetary defense that will help understand which objects may be comets rather than asteroids, how their orbits evolve, and how that influences their Earth impact risks.”
The study also suggests that 1998 SH2 may not be unique. The researchers noted that analyzing the motions of near-Earth objects with increasingly precise astrometry could reveal more hidden comets that have long been classified as asteroids because they lack obvious tails or glowing comas.
As astronomers continue to monitor the growing population of near-Earth objects, subtle orbital changes may prove just as revealing as spectacular comet tails, uncovering more examples of cosmic mistaken identity while helping scientists better understand which objects pose potential threats to Earth.
Their findings were published July 10 in the journal Nature Astronomy.
